We bake in weekly cycles. You can order any time. Each cycle ends Sunday at 11:59pm, and orders placed by then are picked up the following Thursday through Saturday. Order after Sunday night and your box simply joins the next week's pickup.

Pick your box, choose your flavors, then select your pickup day and time at checkout. The upcoming pickup dates are always shown on the home and order pages. Order now →

Fresh-baked cookies and cupcakes, plus catering for larger events. Cookies come in boxes of 4, 8, 12 or 36, and every cookie is individually wrapped and labeled. Cupcakes come in labeled containers of 12 or 24. Everything is baked fresh before pickup.

Box prices depend on size, and larger boxes cost less per cookie. Current prices are on the order page.

Because nothing is made ahead. Monday we shop, Tuesday we prep, Wednesday we make and chill the dough, and every cookie is baked fresh before your pickup. We only buy and bake what was ordered, so nothing sits on a shelf and nothing goes to waste.

Pickup is in Bergen County, NJ. We do not offer delivery. Regular pickup days are Thursday, Friday and Saturday, and we are closed on Sundays. You choose your day and time at checkout, and the exact address and pickup window are in your confirmation email.

When a holiday or its eve falls on a Thursday, pickup moves to the Wednesday before, and we do not bake or hold pickups on the holiday or the day after. Holiday pickup dates are listed on the home page.

Because every order is shopped for and baked fresh, you can get a full refund up to 48 hours before your pickup. After that we are not able to refund, since your order is already in progress. If anything comes up, please text us at (862) 388-5420.

Yes. Our celebration box is for events of 50 or more cookies, and custom cupcake orders start at 36. Catering is available for any date with at least 7 days' notice. Send us an inquiry form and we will put together a custom proposal.

For catering orders only, at an additional cost. Include the details in your inquiry form.

We do not use nuts as ingredients in any recipe. However, we bake in a home kitchen that houses nuts, and some ingredients are made in facilities that process nuts, so we cannot guarantee that anything is nut-free.

buttr. ingredients and equipment are kept separate from household items, with dedicated refrigerator and freezer storage. Our equipment is reserved for buttr. baking, and we take reasonable precautions against cross-contact.

buttr. operates under New Jersey Cottage Food regulations and follows food safety practices for every batch.